idaho native

Official Reports - Re Tyler & Lexington - Pittsburg Landing

6 posts in this topic

This is a document that would have been used to construct the OR (Navy)... How does such an historically valuable logbook end up outside the National Archives? (Scroll down to Lot 640, and read 'description.')  ['Log Book US Gunboat 'Taylor' (Tyler) -beginning August 28, 1861, ending April 1862. Inscribed: 'Lieut. Commanding Wm. Gwin. Produced in a clear, legible hand. Aside from the usual weather reports it talks about happenings on the 'Tennesse', the 'Savannah' and the 'Pittsburgh'.... from Auction House Description.]

 

http://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/7785594

 

 

Ozzy

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Continuing from my previous post...

 

Imagine you are responsible for storing archived government records, and you have one large warehouse at your disposal. During an inspection tour, you discover that the warehouse is full: new records arriving are being left on the loading dock, because there is no more room in the warehouse. Would you:

  • Hire temporary workers to review existing stored records. Determine what is 'most valuable,' and destroy the rest (to make room for freshly arriving documents), or
  • Contract for temporary storage, while a second warehouse is built.

 I ask this question, because there appears to be 'uncertainty' surrounding what is to be done with historical documents: my previous post records an Official Navy Logbook, for sale by an auction house. The following link involves an Official Record of the Lincoln Assassination.

 

Your historical records. What do you want done with them?

 

 

Ozzy

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVdMEFn6MZ8     (Lincoln Assassination police report)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is an example of a 'private diary,' which can be preserved in any manner that the owner deems appropriate (although it would be hoped that the owner would make his holding known to Historians.) This is different from an Official Record, which should be preserved by an approved Government Archivist... not thrown in the trash... not disposed of by an Auction House.

 

Ozzy

 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tzIuo7FNbc     (Michigan man's April 1865 diary)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of interest in the OR (Navy) volume 22 [first reported by Idaho Native] on page 763 of Lieutenant Gwin's April 8 report:

  • 2:50 pm   USS Tyler opened fire on Rebel positions (fire directed by General Hurlbut); firing ceased 3:50 pm.
  • 4pm         USS Lexington opened fire 3/4 mile above Pittsburg Landing. Silenced a Rebel battery in 30 minutes.
  • 5:35 pm    Tyler and Lexington opened on advanced Rebel position 1/8 mile above Pittsburg Landing. Silenced Rebel battery.
  • 6pm          USS Tyler fired on Rebel right wing until 6:25 pm.
  • 9pm          Under direction of General Nelson, USS Tyler fired a 5-  10- or 15-second shell (or occasionally howitzer firing shrapnel) every fifteen minutes during the night of April 6/7. At 1am USS Lexington took over and continued firing until 5am (when firing from gunboats suspended by order of General Grant for remainder of April 7th.)

General Beauregard confirms firing of gunboats against Chalmers position at 3pm on April 6th (Roman page 295.)

Ozzy

 

References:  OR (Navy) volume 22

Roman's Military Ops of PGT Beauregard  http://archive.org/stream/militaryoperatio01roma#page/294/mode/2up 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On page 764 of OR (Navy) volume 22 Lieutenant Gwin itemizes the ammunition USS Tyler expended during April 6th:

  • 188 shell (various fuse timings)
  •     4 solid shot
  •     2 stand of grape shot
  •     6 shrapnel

--------------

          200     total rounds fired (of which sixteen would have been fired from 9pm til 1am, leaving 184 ...fired from 3pm until 6:30 pm, approximate rate of 46 rounds-per-hour. Then add in the rounds fired by USS Lexington during the same period (details not provided) but not unreasonable to assume a similar total. And the average rate of fire exceeds one round-per-minute during 3pm - 6:30 pm.

But, most significant: the details provided on pages 763 and 764 indicate an earlier commencement of firing by the Federal gunboats than many Shiloh enthusiasts realize (before the collapse of the Hornet's Nest.) With the exception of a pause from 4:30 until 5:30, the firing by one or both gunboats was continuous (2:50 pm til 6:25 pm). And lastly, I would suggest 6:25 pm -- the time recorded as when USS Tyler ceased firing -- coincided with sunset. 

Was the artillery fire provided by the Federal gunboats effective?  It did not prevent the collapse of the Hornet's Nest. But it may have "silenced" Gage's Battery. And based on the number of Confederate After-Action reports that mention "firing of the gunboats," those commanders did not indicate willingness to remain "where the shell fragments were landing" ...including OR reports of Withers, Chalmers, Jackson and General Beauregard.

Ozzy

 

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now